Katrina Report Card
Two years after Hurricane Katrina, much has become clear. We know that the devastation in New Orleans and surrounding areas was less a natural than a man-made disaster. Katrina's surge into New Orleans was the direct result of poorly constructed levees, an ill-conceived navigation channel and the destruction of millions of acres of coastal wetlands. Furthermore, the storm's intensity itself was fueled by unusually warm waters in the tropical Atlantic due, in part, to global warming pollution.
How have Congress and the Administration responded to these lessons of Katrina and addressed the chief causes of its tragic aftermath? Read NWF's report card on the federal government's response to global warming, reforming the Army Corps of Engineers and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), and restoring the wetlands along the Gulf Coast that act as a natural buffer to storms.
ADDRESSING GLOBAL WARMING
Congress Grade: C
Congress has shown significant improvement since its failing grade last year. Both the House and Senate passed energy bills, each taking first steps toward a new energy future. However, Congress has yet to send the final bill to the President's desk because the energy bills must be conferenced (planned after Labor Day, when Congress reconvenes). Serious committee consideration is only beginning on cap and trade legislation to place mandatory limits on global warming pollution from major emitters. Such legislation is needed to promptly begin reducing global warming pollution by two percent every year--20 percent per decade--to achieve the pollution reductions scientists say are needed. Congress could pull its C grade up to an A in the next few months by finishing the energy bill, and accelerating work on cap and trade legislation.
Greatest Success:
Passage of stronger vehicle efficiency standards (Corporate Average Fuel Economy, or CAFE) in the Senate and a Renewable Electricity Standard in the House.
Greatest failure:
Congress has yet to deliver final global warming and clean energy bills to the President's desk.
Administration Grade: F
Recently, the President acknowledged global warming is real, humans are causing it and something needs to be done. The Administration will host an international summit on climate change in Washington, D.C. in September. But the Administration continues to oppose comprehensive legislation that would cut U.S. global warming pollution from today's levels. We can't solve global warming without reducing the pollution that causes it. The United States has a responsibility to take action ahead of other countries that have contributed less to the problem, and should pursue the economic opportunities in having American businesses lead the way to solving the problem.
Upcoming events present an opportunity to change course. After more than six years of delay, the Administration needs to be a leader, not an obstacle, on the fight to reduce global warming pollution.
Greatest Success:
Acknowledging in the 2007 State of the Union the need to "confront the serious challenge of global climate change” and convening an upcoming climate change summit in Washington DC.
Greatest Failure:
Remains opposed to mandatory cuts in pollution from today’s levels and clean energy policies such as a federal standard to bolster renewable electricity sources. The Administration has 17 months before the President leaves office to change course.
“Many American coastal communities may face more intense storms as the oceans continue to warm and coastal sea levels rise in the decades ahead. We can and must do better to prevent the worst impacts of global warming and restore wetlands and barrier islands along our shores that serve as buffers against these storms.” – Larry Schweiger, president and CEO, National Wildlife Federation
The full report, which is available at www.nwf.org/hurricanes, includes sections on:
Addressing global warming
Reforming the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Fixing FEMA
Restoring the Coast
Learn more about the science behind hurricanes: www.nwf.org/hurricanes/hurricanescience.cfm














The Federal Government and the Corps of Engineers need to take drastic measures to undo the problems they have created.
They also need to pay more attention to academics and naturalist groups which have been warning of the problems for some time.
One of the first things to be done is to let the Mississipi River return to a natural state and let sediment build up at the delta so that the buffer zone will return and lessen the strength of hurricanes in New Orleans.
Posted by: Sandra Zastrow | September 04, 2007 at 07:09 PM
There has been so much money donated to the Katrina victims. Just our church donated over a million dollars. So much of the money has been wasted. A person from New Orleans just shot and killed a great football player from Spring Westfield High School. There is a lot of money somewhere. Is it in the pocket of Louisiana politicans?
Posted by: Grandmothet | September 04, 2007 at 07:09 PM
Oh God Grandmother. You don't sound much like any grandmother I know. Thank you for the donation of a million dollars by your church, but who exactly did you donate it to? If you don't know, you can hardly complain about how the money is spent. A significant part of the problem is that people are doing the same things they've always done, when what's needed in New Orleans is something different. Criticized for his lack of concern for New Orleans, in particular, President Bush keeps saying the nation has already spent over $114 billion. But of that amount, about $60 billion was for Louisiana. The majority of that went to major military contractors to remove debris, which leaves us with what? Still broken levees and levee walls, a broken sewer and water system and broken streets due to subsidence. You'll see broken empty houses for miles. You can't just throw money at a problem like this. It requires leadership, something lacking from every level of government. So who's getting screwed? The people you thought you were helping, because the money goes through an inverted funnel where a gatekeeper decides how it gets spent. Corruption? Sure, New Orleans officials are being prosecuted left and right thanks to vigorous US Attorney and FBI offices here -- can you say that about your own community? Every place has corruption. We're cleaning it up. By the way, not one dollar of money allocated to local officials has lined anyone's pockets. Every instance of money misspent was money allocated by FEMA -- a federal agency. Don't give up on us. We continue to need the help. Come down here and help build a house. Help teach in a classroom. Help stop historic homes from being demolished. Help give hope to children fighting to survive in an environment of depravity. Help with the worst mental health crisis this nation has ever experienced thanks to the hopelessness exacerbated by comments like the one you made.
Posted by: Schroeder | September 06, 2007 at 09:40 AM
What is your point that "..every instance of money misspent was money allocated by FEMA.." If true, lets just turn all the money over to the great State of Louisiana and the great City of New Orleans and let them spend the money directly. I am sure that New Orleans will be returned to former greatness in just a couple of years!
Posted by: Keith | September 11, 2007 at 07:26 PM